Welcome to our store

Pencil Me In!

Placeholder for Possible Order

Do you have an upcoming celebration and want cookies/cake/cupcakes, but still not exactly sure what you want? Let Nifty Cookies help with our "Pencil Me In" program! Simply provide us with your event's approximate date, the estimated number of cookies/cake/cupcakes you'll need, and we'll mark your spot on our calendar. About a month before your event, I will reach out by email to finalize your design and details. We recommend reserving your spot early, as multiple requests happen around those special times of the year—though if you’re planning ahead, we’ll happily mark your event on our calendar, even a year out! By being penciled in, your order will take priority (based on order of request) over any last minute orders and you will avoid hearing "Sorry, I can't". Please note, submitting this form does not commit you to ordering any desserts. Orders are confirmed once the 50% deposit or payment is made in full. "Penciling in" is completely free, and if your plans change—whether it's the date, quantity, design, or cancelation—it’s no problem at all. With enough notice, we’re flexible to accommodate your needs. Once everything is finalized, you’ll pay for your order and then eagerly await your custom creations, right before your event! To get started, simply book your date--"Pencil In" today!

Custom Order Season Was Incredible

August 2, 2026

From February through July, our kitchen was overflowing with butter, royal icing, and sprinkles.

We were honored to create custom cookies and cakes for:

Birthday celebrations
Baby showers
Cinco de Mayo parties
Corporate conferences
Appreciation events
Family celebrations
And so many other special occasions

Every order tells a different story, and it's always an honor to be part of your celebrations. Whether it's a dozen logo cookies for a business event or a birthday cake for someone turning five (or seventy-five!), I never take that trust for granted.

Thank you to every customer who chose Nifty Cookies to help celebrate life's sweetest moments.

Back to blog